Assignment: Cause-Effect and Argument

Cause and Effect and Argument Essay

Length: 3-5 pages

Due date:

Description of assignment:

You will write an argumentative essay that supports a claim or assertion and identifies causes and/or effects of your supporting statements. Secondary sources are not required. If you include secondary sources for supporting evidence, you must document your sources in MLA format. Double-space your essay in 12-point Times New Roman font.

Goal of assignment:

Argumentative essays assert the soundness of a debatable position, belief, or conclusion. Arguments examine ideas to persuade readers to accept new ideas or to take new actions.

Skills we will work on with this paper:

  • Creating a clear, debatable thesis statement
  • Developing supporting paragraphs
  • Organizing effective arguments
  • Avoiding illogical, fallacious reasoning

Suggestions for topics:

  • Do social networking sites do more harm than good?
  • Should patients have the right to die via physician-assisted suicide?
  • Should states establish more rigid gun control laws to buy weapons?
  • Your own. (Must have instructor’s approval)


Thesis/Claim = 20%

Debatable claim/developed purpose. 20-18 points

Debatable claim/purpose fair. 17-16 points

Debatable claim/purpose vague. 15-14 points

Unclear/question. 13-12 points

Missing/not relevant. 11-0 points 


Supporting Evidence/Content = 30%

Support links to thesis/well-developed details/rhetorical elements addressed. 27-30 points

Support links to thesis/developed details/two rhetorical elements addressed. 26-24 points

Extraneous information included/one rhetorical element included/support not explicitly linked to thesis. 23-21 points

Extraneous information included/support not linked to thesis/rhetorical elements not present. 20-18 points

Ideas are unrelated to thesis/rhetorical elements not present/extraneous information included. 17-00 points


Organization = 30%

Logical and coherent/effective transitions guide argument. 30-27 points 

Logical and coherent/strong transitions. 26-24 points

Progression of ideas awkward/transitions missing. 23-21 points

Missing essay paragraphs/transitions missing. 20-18 points

Lacks structure/incoherent/illogical. 17-00 points


Grammar/Mechanics = 20%

Punctuation/mechanics appropriate. 20-18 points

Errors do not interfere with meaning. 17-16 points

Repeated errors. Meaning clear. 15-14 points

Errors interfere with meaning. 13-12 points

Unclear/multiple errors. 11-00 points


Possibilities (the best essays do this):

Argumentation is a process of reasoning that asserts the soundness of a debatable position, idea, belief, or course of action. Arguments clearly articulate the writer’s position and persuade readers to share the writer’s perspective and insight.

Consider your purpose and your audience. What do you expect your argument to accomplish? Successful arguments should:

  • Clearly state a debatable thesis
  • Present relevant, honest evidence that supports your thesis
  • Acknowledge the opposing viewpoints related to your claim
  • Provide coherent organization with appropriate transitions
  • Proofread, revise, and edit carefully

Pitfalls (common mistakes students make with this assignment):

To establish credibility in your argument, avoid these common errors:

  • Do not create a question for your thesis statement.
  • Do not create a self-evident/factual thesis statement.
  • Do not over-simplify the evidence in your argument.
  • Do not create illogical or fallacious evidence that is deceptive and dishonest.
  • Do not ignore opposing viewpoints.
  • Do not use personal attacks as evidence.




Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

Writing Rhetorically: Framing First Year Writing Copyright © 2022 by LOUIS: The Louisiana Library Network is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.

Share This Book